Unravelling the Canine Connection: New Study Challenges Dog Domestication Theories
Share
Recent research is adding layers of complexity to our understanding of how dogs became humanity's best friend. A new study suggests that the seemingly more affectionate and submissive behaviours dogs display towards humans compared to wolves might not be solely a product of domestication, hinting at the significant, and perhaps unconscious, influence of human behaviour itself.
Key Takeaways
- Dogs exhibit more human-directed behaviours than wolves, but the reasons remain debated.
- Human responses to dogs and wolves differ, potentially influencing animal behaviour.
- Ear posture and subtle facial expressions show some species differences, but their interpretation is complicated by human biases.
The Enduring Mystery of Dog Domestication
For millennia, dogs have shared our lives, developing traits like tail wagging, sustained eye contact, and expressive faces, often attributed to their domestication. Scientists have long sought to understand the driving forces behind this unique social bond, with theories suggesting dogs are either "hypersocial" or more deferential to humans.
However, evidence that wolves raised with humans can also engage in cooperative and social interactions challenges the notion that these behaviours are exclusively a result of domestication. This raises a crucial question: did these human-oriented traits emerge during domestication, or were they already present in ancestral wolves?
A Closer Look at Canine and Wolf Interactions
To investigate this, researchers compared the facial expressions and greeting behaviours of human-socialised dogs and wolves. The study, conducted at the Wolf Science Center in Austria, involved hand-raised animals familiar with human interaction. Eleven dogs and eleven wolves participated, with an additional group of pet dogs included to control for ear shape variations.
Animals were greeted by both a strongly bonded human and a more casually familiar one, through a fence to mimic typical interactions. Researchers meticulously coded facial movements using systems like DogFACS, alongside other social signals such as tail wagging and gaze direction. Human facial expressions were also recorded to identify potential biases.
Findings: More Than Just Domestication?
Overall, dogs spent more time near humans, wagged their tails more, and maintained eye contact more frequently than wolves. Both species showed stronger engagement with their bonded human. Dogs also displayed more displacement behaviours, like whining, particularly towards their primary caretakers.
Facial analysis revealed that dogs were more likely to raise their inner eyebrows and slightly more likely to raise their upper lips. However, these differences were modest, and their precise emotional meanings are still unclear. Other facial expressions did not differ significantly between the species.
Ear movements, however, showed more pronounced differences. Wolves tended to hold their ears forward, often associated with confidence, while dogs more frequently rotated or lowered their ears, signals often interpreted as submission or uncertainty. These patterns held true even when controlling for ear shape.
The Human Factor: Unconscious Biases at Play
Crucially, the study found significant differences in human facial expressions based on the species they were interacting with. Humans displayed more intense, frequent, and positively valanced expressions when greeting dogs compared to wolves, even among experienced handlers instructed to treat both species equally.
This suggests that humans may harbour implicit biases, responding to dogs with more warmth and expressiveness. These subtle human reactions could, in turn, influence how animals behave, complicating efforts to isolate the effects of domestication alone.
Future Directions
While the study provides valuable insights, its small sample size is a limitation. Future research aims to increase sample sizes, use time-series analysis to disentangle the direction of influence between humans and animals, and explore the origins of human biases. Understanding these dynamics is key to a more accurate picture of dog domestication and improving human-animal coexistence.